Why does Punchies Chooses Raw Organic Sugar Over Artificial and Ultra-Processed Sweeteners? For parents who care about what goes into their kids’ bodies, today’s snack aisle is overwhelming. Dozens of brands promote gummies and bars with buzzwords like “keto-friendly,” low sugar protein snacks, or “no sugar added.” But behind these claims are ingredients many families may not recognize—or want—in a child’s daily snack.
At Punchies, we believe real, simple ingredients matter most. That’s why we use only raw organic cane sugar, never artificial sweeteners, sugar alcohols, syrups, or processed alternatives. Here’s what every parent should know about what’s really inside most so-called “healthy” or low sugar protein snacks, and why Punchies takes a different path.
The Truth About Alternative Sweeteners in Low Sugar Protein Snacks
To cut sugar, many brands use a rotating cast of sweeteners in their low sugar protein snacks. Some are natural in origin, but most are made through industrial processing, and almost all come with side effects or drawbacks—especially for kids.
Sugar Alcohols: Sorbitol, Maltitol, Erythritol
Sugar alcohols like sorbitol, maltitol, and erythritol are popular in sugar-free candies and low sugar protein snacks. They’re made by hydrogenating sugars from corn or wheat. While these ingredients add bulk and sweetness, the European Food Safety Authority and FDA both caution that sugar alcohols can cause digestive distress in children. Even moderate portions often lead to bloating, gas, or diarrhea—effects well documented in clinical studies and real-world use. Maltitol is especially likely to trigger stomach upset in kids.
Allulose, Monk Fruit, and Fiber Syrups in Low Sugar Protein Products
Newer “novel” sweeteners, such as allulose and monk fruit, are now common in so-called low sugar protein snacks. Allulose is manufactured from corn using enzymatic processing. Monk fruit, though plant-derived, is almost always blended with sugar alcohols like erythritol for texture and bulk. While these are generally recognized as safe, long-term studies in children are limited. For parents reading ingredient lists, these sweeteners are unfamiliar and often raise questions about safety and transparency.
Industrial "fiber" syrups (including isomalto-oligosaccharides and soluble corn fiber) are used to cut calories and add “prebiotic fiber” claims. However, research shows that many of these syrups are digested like sugar and contribute calories in much the same way. The FDA has required that these industrial “fiber” syrups now be listed as added sugars because they behave more like carbohydrates than true fibers.
Inulin, Oligofructose, and Prebiotic Fillers in Kids’ Snacks
Prebiotic fillers such as inulin and oligofructose are extracted from chicory root, agave, or similar plants. While these fibers are naturally occurring, they are ultra-processed and can cause gas, bloating, or even diarrhea at modest serving sizes. These fillers are often used to bulk up snacks without providing real nutrition or energy.
Why We Don’t Use Honey in Our Low Sugar Protein Snacks
You may wonder why Punchies doesn’t use honey. While honey is natural, independent laboratory testing—including a 2022 study by The Detox Project—has shown that over 60% of commercial honey in the United States contains traces of glyphosate, a common agricultural herbicide. For a product designed for kids, there’s no acceptable risk when it comes to chemical residues.
Why We Stick With Raw Organic Cane Sugar for Low Sugar Protein Snacks
Raw organic cane sugar is simply sugar, extracted from organically grown sugarcane, with minimal processing. At Punchies, we use just 4 grams per serving to make our low sugar protein snacks. This modest amount is less than half the sugar found in most leading fruit snacks or granola bars and keeps Punchies firmly in the low sugar protein snacks category. Parents recognize and trust sugar. Used responsibly, it is easy for children to digest, doesn’t mask taste with artificial aftertastes, and avoids the stomach discomfort common with many sugar substitutes.
By using organic sugar, we also ensure our product remains non-GMO and free from pesticide and herbicide residues commonly found in conventional sweeteners and syrups. The organic certification gives parents another layer of confidence about what’s in the package.
Sweetener Comparison Table
| Sweetener | Source/Processing | Digestive Tolerance | Contamination Risk | Label Transparency | Empty Calories or Filler? | Used by Punchies? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw Organic Cane Sugar | Organic sugarcane, minimally processed | Gentle at 4g/serving, no GI upset | Low (organic, non-GMO, pesticide-free) | Recognizable and familiar to parents | No – Real energy, not filler | ✔️ Yes |
| Sorbitol / Maltitol (Sugar Alcohols) | Ultra-processed, industrial, hydrogenated from corn or wheat | High risk of gas, bloating, diarrhea | Low | Often hidden as "sugar-free" | Yes – Filler with no nutritional value | ❌ No |
| Erythritol | Ultra-processed, Fermented from corn/starch | Better than others, but GI upset possible at higher amounts | Low | Unfamiliar to many parents | Yes - Low calorie, no nutritional value, empty calories | ❌ No |
| Monk Fruit | Ultra-processed, then usually blended with erythritol | GI upset risk if blended with polyols | Low | Unfamiliar; ingredient lists are confusing | Yes - Used as a filler/bulk agents, no nutritional value | ❌ No |
| Allulose | Ultra-processed from corn fructose | Generally well tolerated, but limited studies in kids | Low | Label unfamiliar to most parents | Yes - Low calorie, no nutritional value, empty sweetener | ❌ No |
| Honey | Natural, but often contaminated (glyphosate) | Well tolerated in most, but not suitable for infants | Glyphosate detected in most store honey | Familiar, but purity is uncertain | No – Real energy, but purity concern | ❌ No |
| IMO, Soluble Corn Fiber, Inulin | Ultra-processed industrial syrups | Can cause gas or loose stools at modest amounts | Low | Labeled as "fiber," but parents may not recognize it | Yes – Mostly filler, no nutritional value | ❌ No |
Ingredient Simplicity, Transparency, and Trust in Low Sugar Protein Snacks
Punchies never uses:
- Sorbitol, maltitol, erythritol, or any other sugar alcohols
- Monk fruit, stevia, allulose, or isomalto-oligosaccharides
- Soluble corn fiber, inulin, or oligofructose syrup
- High-fructose corn syrup or any artificial sweeteners
- Honey or agave (due to contamination concerns)
Instead, every serving of Punchies gummies contains:
- 5g high-quality, complete protein from grass-fed whey isolate and collagen
- 4g raw organic cane sugar
- 100% daily vitamin C
- Organic fruit flavors and organic tapioca
- No synthetic dyes, no artificial preservatives, no “mystery” ingredients
The Bottom Line: Better for Kids, Trusted by Parents Seeking Low Sugar Protein Snacks
Every serving of Punchies delivers balanced, honest nutrition with ingredients you can pronounce and trust. Our gummies support growing muscles, immunity, and energy—without the fillers, “new” sweeteners, or digestion issues found in most snacks labeled as low sugar protein snacks. The result: a snack kids love, and parents feel good about.
Sources: